Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind

by Well-Trained Mind Press

ElaGrades 5–12

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind: Structured Classical Grammar Program

Grammar for the Well-Trained Mind is a comprehensive classical grammar curriculum for grades 5-12 that uses scripted lessons and repeated instruction cycles with different workbooks each year. The program emphasizes memorization, sentence diagramming, and direct instruction through a teacher-led approach that covers grammar, usage, punctuation, and sentence structure over four years.

Best for

Homeschooling families or small group settings seeking intensive grammar instruction through classical, teacher-led methods with students who respond well to structured, repetitive learning

Evaluation Criteria

3 strengths · 3 concerns · 1 neutral · 2 insufficient evidence

Teacher TrainingStrength

The curriculum provides extensive teacher support through scripted lessons and detailed instructions.

The approach 'makes teaching easy, eliminating lesson planning or concerns about how to present lessons' with 'entirely scripted' lessons showing exactly what teachers should say and do

Direct InstructionStrength

The curriculum employs highly structured direct instruction with scripted lessons.

The Core Instructor Text has '130 lessons that are entirely scripted and show what the teacher is to say and do and how the student is to respond' using 'direct teaching and clear, detailed instructions'

Retrieval PracticeStrength

The curriculum incorporates systematic review and memorization practices.

Students 'memorize and recite definitions, rules, conjugations, and lists' and 'periodic, cumulative review is built into the lessons' with dedicated review weeks

Knowledge RichConcern

This is primarily a grammar-focused curriculum that does not systematically build domain knowledge across subjects.

The program 'teaches grammar, usage, punctuation, capitalization, and sentence structure' with no mention of content knowledge building

Vocabulary BuildingConcern

The curriculum does not appear to include systematic vocabulary instruction.

Review focuses entirely on grammar instruction with no mention of vocabulary development or word study

Whole Books Vs ExcerptsConcern

The curriculum uses sentences and paragraphs from fiction and non-fiction rather than complete works.

Review states 'The bulk of each lesson in the workbooks consists of exercises that use sentences and paragraphs from fiction and non-fiction'

Writing InstructionNeutral

The curriculum includes some writing assignments but appears limited in scope.

Review mentions 'writing assignments' that students complete 'on their own paper or in a notebook' but provides no details about writing instruction

Text ComplexityInsufficient Evidence

Cannot assess text complexity as the curriculum uses excerpted sentences and paragraphs rather than complete texts.

Review mentions exercises use 'sentences and paragraphs from fiction and non-fiction' but provides no information about text complexity levels

Systematic PhonicsInsufficient Evidence

Not applicable for this grammar-focused curriculum designed for grades 5-12.

Program is designed for grades 5-12, well beyond the phonics instruction years

Review Sources

cathyduffy

Cathy Duffy

Key Facts
GradesGrades 5–12
SubjectEla
PedagogyClassical
Pricing$51.03 at Amazon.com | $5.74 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $26.95 at Rainbowresource.com | $26.85 at Christianbook.com | $29.96 at Amazon.com | $4.68 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $26.95 at Rainbowresource.com | $24.09 at Christianbook.com | $27.85 at Amazon.com | $3.38 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $24.25 at Rainbowresource.com | $16.96 at Amazon.com | $8.98 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $12.39 at Christianbook.com | $12.50 at Rainbowresource.com | $42.19 at Christianbook.com | $37.25 at Rainbowresource.com | $37.25 at Rainbowresource.com | $10.83 at Christianbook.com | $18.95 at Amazon.com | $9.71 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $12.25 at Rainbowresource.com | $8.49 at Amazon.com | $4.52 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $4.52 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $12.19 at Christianbook.com | $12.25 at Rainbowresource.com | $32.36 at Amazon.com | $20.19 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $20.19 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $28.26 at Christianbook.com | $26.95 at Rainbowresource.com | $37.25 at Rainbowresource.com

Looking for something different?

If none of these options feel right, explore a non-traditional approach. Pallas Center offers a unique curriculum, or design your own with Palladay.

Data sources: cathyduffy