Historical Stories of Survival

by Justine Gamblehttp://www.historicalstoriesofsurvival.com/

Social_studiesGrades 2–5

Historical Stories of Survival: Literature-Based Historical Event Studies

Historical Stories of Survival is a unit study curriculum based on Scholastic's "I Survived" historical fiction series, covering specific dramatic historical events from 79 AD to 2011. Each 6-week study uses literature as a launching point for multidisciplinary exploration including history, science, geography, and language arts activities centered around events like the Great Chicago Fire, Pearl Harbor, and Mount St. Helens.

Best for

Homeschooling families seeking literature-based unit studies who want multidisciplinary exploration of dramatic historical events and prefer flexible, activity-rich learning over systematic historical instruction

Evaluation Criteria

1 strength · 2 concerns · 2 neutral · 2 insufficient evidence

Geographic KnowledgeStrength

The curriculum incorporates geography activities as part of its multidisciplinary approach. Geography expands beyond the immediate location of events to include broader regional study and map work.

The Great Chicago Fire study 'expands beyond Chicago to the state of Illinois as well as Minnesota, Massachusetts, Wisconsin, and the Dakota Territory' with activities that 'contrast maps of both past and present'

Direct InstructionConcern

The curriculum follows a unit study approach with activity-based learning rather than direct instruction. Parents and teachers need to provide their own instructional framework using the suggested resources and activities.

The format involves students reading books, creating lapbooks, and completing various activities, with the reviewer noting this 'will probably appeal most to parents and teachers who appreciate flexibility rather than those looking for step-by-step lesson plans'

Chronological KnowledgeConcern

The curriculum does not build systematic chronological knowledge, instead focusing on isolated dramatic events across different time periods. Students study individual historical moments without connecting them to broader historical narratives or timelines.

Studies cover disparate events from 79 AD Pompeii to 2011 Joplin Tornado with no systematic progression, and the reviewer notes they 'provide only minimal instruction for history itself'

Teacher TrainingNeutral

The curriculum provides some instructional support for parents unfamiliar with unit studies and lapbooking. However, it requires significant teacher preparation and resource gathering.

The guide 'provides instructions for creating lapbooks in case that is something new to you' and includes charts and activity lists, though teachers 'will need to gather supplies' and make 'choices and adaptations'

Vocabulary BuildingNeutral

The curriculum includes vocabulary work as part of its language arts components. Each study appears to address subject-specific terminology related to the historical event being studied.

Language arts activities specifically include 'vocabulary' alongside reading comprehension, spelling, and writing activities

Primary SourcesInsufficient Evidence

There is insufficient evidence about primary source usage in the curriculum materials. The focus appears to be on historical fiction books and supplementary library resources rather than historical documents.

The review mentions reading historical fiction novels and library books but does not describe engagement with primary source documents or historical evidence

Retrieval PracticeInsufficient Evidence

There is insufficient evidence of systematic retrieval practice or spaced review in the curriculum design. The focus appears to be on project-based learning during each 6-week unit.

The review describes various activities and projects but does not mention review mechanisms or retrieval practice to ensure retention of historical knowledge

Review Sources

cathyduffy

Cathy Duffy

Key Facts
GradesGrades 2–5
SubjectSocial_studies
PedagogyUnit Study
Faith-BasedNo

Looking for something different?

If none of these options feel right, explore a non-traditional approach. Pallas Center offers a unique curriculum, or design your own with Palladay.

Data sources: cathyduffy, homeschoolcom