Stories of the Pilgrims, second edition

ElaAll Grades

Stories of the Pilgrims: Historical Reader for Elementary Students

Stories of the Pilgrims, second edition is a historical reader that presents Pilgrim history through story format for elementary students. The book tracks the Pilgrims' journey from England through Holland to their pioneering adventures in America, featuring key historical figures and including comprehension questions after each story.

Best for

Elementary teachers (grades 3-4) seeking knowledge-rich historical content for reading instruction, homeschool families wanting to integrate American history with reading, and educators looking for read-aloud materials for younger students

Evaluation Criteria

3 strengths · 1 concern · 2 neutral · 3 insufficient evidence

Knowledge RichStrength

The curriculum systematically builds domain knowledge about American colonial history and key historical figures.

Students learn about key characters such as William Bradford, William Brewster, John Alden, Miles Standish, and important Native Americans like Samoset and Squanto, covering the Pilgrims' journey from England through Holland to America

Text ComplexityStrength

The text is appropriately leveled for third or fourth graders with good readability features.

The reading level is described as 'appropriate for third or fourth graders' with 'large and dark' print in a 'large, softcover format'

Whole Books Vs ExcerptsStrength

This is a complete book rather than a collection of excerpts, providing sustained narrative about Pilgrim history.

The book 'tells of this brief but important time in America's history in story form' and 'tracks the adventures of the Pilgrims' in a complete narrative arc from England to America

Teacher TrainingConcern

Limited teacher support materials beyond the companion answer key.

A companion answer key is mentioned as available, but no additional teacher training or professional development materials are described

Direct InstructionNeutral

The format includes comprehension questions that could support direct instruction, though specific teaching guidance is unclear.

The book includes 'comprehension questions follow each brief story' and has 'a companion answer key,' suggesting structured assessment tools

Retrieval PracticeNeutral

Comprehension questions after each story provide some retrieval practice opportunities.

The book includes comprehension questions following each brief story, which could serve as retrieval practice for content covered

Systematic PhonicsInsufficient Evidence

No evidence of phonics instruction provided in the available materials.

The review focuses on the historical content and reading level but makes no mention of phonics instruction or decoding support

Vocabulary BuildingInsufficient Evidence

Limited evidence of explicit vocabulary instruction beyond exposure to historical terms and names.

The book introduces historical vocabulary through character names and historical context, but no explicit vocabulary instruction methods are described

Writing InstructionInsufficient Evidence

No evidence of structured writing instruction included in this reader.

The review mentions only comprehension questions following each story, with no reference to writing activities or instruction

Review Sources

cathyduffy

Cathy Duffy

Key Facts
GradesAll Grades
SubjectEla
PedagogyNot specified
Pricing$9.98 at Christianbook.com | $7.35 at Amazon.com | $2.36 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $3.74 at Christianbook.com | $3.75 at Rainbowresource.com

Looking for something different?

If none of these options feel right, explore a non-traditional approach. Pallas Center offers a unique curriculum, or design your own with Palladay.

Data sources: cathyduffy