Challenge Math Series

MathGrades 1–8

About This Curriculum

Supplemental math series featuring challenging word problems at multiple difficulty levels designed for gifted and advanced students.

What makes it unique: Real-world problem solving with multiple difficulty levels (3-4 levels per topic) that challenge gifted students beyond typical textbooks

Challenge Math Series: Supplemental Problem-Solving for Gifted Students

The Challenge Math Series is a collection of supplemental math books by Ed Zaccaro designed to provide challenging, multi-step word problems for gifted and advanced students in grades 1-8. The series features three main books with problems at multiple difficulty levels, emphasizing real-world applications and complex problem-solving rather than procedural drill work.

Best for

Gifted and advanced students in grades 1-8 who need challenging problem-solving practice as a supplement to their core math curriculum, particularly those who enjoy puzzle-like mathematical challenges

Evaluation Criteria

2 strengths · 5 concerns · 2 neutral

Word ProblemsStrength

Exceptional strength in word problem instruction with multi-step, real-world applications. Problems require complex reasoning and multiple mathematical techniques.

Described as providing 'word problems that will challenge both their math and thinking skills' with examples requiring 'multiple steps in math rather than simple one-step solutions.' Problems involve 'arithmetic calculations in meaningful contexts.'

Sequencing ApproachStrength

Uses a mastery-based approach with graded difficulty levels within topics. The series allows flexible pacing based on student readiness.

Problems are organized in 3-4 difficulty levels (Level 1 easy, Level 2 challenging, Level 3/Einstein very challenging) with recommendation that 'brightest students work through some of the easier problems to ensure that they have easier concepts mastered.'

Teacher TrainingConcern

Minimal teacher support provided. Books include answer keys but lack pedagogical guidance or mathematical background for instructors.

Each book 'includes its own answer key at the back' but no mention of teacher guides, mathematical explanations for teachers, or instructional strategies.

Direct InstructionConcern

Not designed for direct instruction delivery. Students work independently through problems with minimal teacher-led instruction.

Noted that 'students are likely to work through lessons on their own' and the books serve as supplements alongside core instruction programs.

Retrieval PracticeConcern

Limited emphasis on retrieval practice. Focus is on novel problem-solving rather than review of previously learned skills.

One reviewer mentions 'moving between different Zaccaro books as needed' but no systematic spaced review or retrieval practice is described.

Assessment DiagnosticConcern

No systematic assessment tools provided. The multiple difficulty levels may serve as informal diagnostic indicators.

The graded difficulty levels could help identify student readiness, but no formal diagnostic assessments or progress monitoring tools are mentioned.

Conceptual Procedural BalanceConcern

The curriculum emphasizes conceptual understanding and problem-solving application over procedural fluency. It assumes students receive systematic procedural instruction elsewhere.

Described as supplements that 'assume students are receiving systematic instruction elsewhere' and focus on 'word problems that will challenge both their math and thinking skills' rather than procedural practice.

Worked ExamplesNeutral

Provides some worked examples and explanations within problem sets. More thorough explanations are given for advanced topics students haven't encountered before.

Topics are 'presented with instruction and examples, often in the form of word problems with illustrations' and 'explanations are more thorough' for advanced concepts.

Visual RepresentationsNeutral

Limited visual support mentioned, with some illustrations accompanying word problems. Not a primary focus of the curriculum.

Problems include 'illustrations' but no specific mention of manipulatives, number lines, or other visual models for building conceptual understanding.

Review Sources

web_search

Navigating By Joy

cathyduffy

Cathy Duffy

Key Facts
GradesGrades 1–8
SubjectMath
PedagogyInquiry Based
Faith-BasedNo
FormatPhysical
Pricing$24.95 at Amazon.com | $2.59 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $22.95 at Rainbowresource.com | $27.95 at Amazon.com | $10.86 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $22.95 at Rainbowresource.com | $26.95 at Amazon.com | $2.28 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $21.95 at Rainbowresource.com | $26.95 at Amazon.com | $2.96 Used at Amazon.com Marketplace | $21.95 at Rainbowresource.com

Looking for something different?

If none of these options feel right, explore a non-traditional approach. Pallas Center offers a unique curriculum, or design your own with Palladay.

Data sources: cathyduffy